8.1 with flop?? Dude was definitely bullied into that. Lol     See Less

Im from Bensonhurst Brooklyn born and raised but i go to the new haven area pretty regular because of my job as a professional poker player i stop by when going to foxwood or the sun or enco     See More on I've been here 3 times imo they have a legit pizza i also like sallys more but this place is legit    See Less

Owners and managers need to stay off the field. Dave needs a rail.     See Less

Yes! Matt!!!     See Less

I knew he would complain about the flop. olde world is amazing.     See Less

Mr. Pizza in the apron behind the counter, classic muscle car calendar, and the pizza has a little kick. Yo, I'm booking my flight right now. ✈️ 🍕     See Less

It's all about preference. I grew up in New Haven and have had all of them. I personally like olde world because I like more cheese on my pizza and I don't mind a little flop. If you     See More ispy no flop Pizza definitely go with Sally's but if you like more cheese and toppings, olde world and modern are really good. Also, the calzones at these New Haven spots are phenomenal and shouldn't be overlooked.    See Less

Leave it in the box another 30 mins and you can use a fork haha.     See Less

More like 6.2 ?     See Less

Honestly by looking at the photos on the Google review, they deserved the 8.1 score. Their pies look fucking awesome.     See Less